What's New

Two Agent Positions with PEI Mutual Insurance Company


Are you highly organized and self-motivated with a passion for member service? Do you take pride in your professionalism and ability to build and maintain strong client and stakeholder relationships? If so, PEI Mutual Insurance Company would love to hear from you!

After 43 years of providing outstanding service and commitment to our great Island Company and our loyal policyholders, our Agent, Bruce Simpson is planning for a well-deserved retirement. This opens an exciting opportunity for 2 new Agents to serve in the area identified in the map below.

We offer:

  • A safe and respectful work environment
  • Our Agents work from their home office
  • Our Agents are provided with a Company vehicle for PEI Mutual business purposes
  • Dental, health, and vision care benefits paid by the company
  • One of PEI's best defined-contribution pension plans (RRSP) matched by the company
  • Various employee well-being initiatives and wellness challenges
  • Insurance education and development opportunities
  • The opportunity to work with an inspiring team of co-workers
Our Agents are an important part of the organization's success, and often serve as the face of PEI Mutual in our Island communities.

Founded over 137 years ago, with roots in our Island's primary resources, PEI Mutual is proud to be PEI's largest property and casualty insurer!

What you'll do:
Reporting to the Agency Manager and serving as a member of our Insurance Agent team, this position offers an opportunity to enhance our member/policyholder service and sales focus.
  • Provide a high level of personalized service to fit our members' needs
  • Proactively manage new and existing member coverage
  • Build trusting relationships with our members, staff, and community stakeholders
  • Visit members' properties and conduct periodic policy reviews to ensure offerings are up to date
  • Maintain and submit accurate and timely reports
  • Monitor market trends to make adjustments when needed
About you:
  • Strong customer-oriented focus
  • Excellent attention to detail, time management, and multi-tasking skills
  • Positive ambitious attitude, with excellent communication and interpersonal skills
  • You have a broad knowledge of Prince Edward Island, its people, and industries
  • Committed to continuous insurance education and development opportunities
  • Work well independently and in a team environment
  • A self-starter, with a demonstrated ability to manage priorities, schedule, and promptly respond to inquiries
  • A demonstrated and well-defined sense of diplomacy and ethics
  • Adaptable, and available to serve our members outside of usual working hours
  • Community minded and engaged in community service
  • Possess a valid driver's license
  • Your values align with PEI Mutual's core values:
    • We listen and respond to our members' needs;
    • We behave with integrity;
    • We treat each other with dignity and respect;
    • We support, motivate and engage our talent;
    • We continuously improve and innovate;
    • We give back to the local communities we serve; and
    • We are accountable collectively and individually.
  • Experience or knowledge in the Insurance Industry considered an asset
  • Will reside in one of the two areas assigned and possess a good knowledge of the area
Our positive culture is important to us! If you are highly people-focused and look forward to adding to our culture, please send your resume outlining your experience for consideration.

Salary Range: $65,000 - $85,000 annually, depending on skills and years of experience.

Apply to: Agent Position, by Wednesday, August 10th, 2022.

PEI Mutual Announces Craig Noonan as new CEO


On behalf of the CEO Hiring Committee and PEI Mutual's Board of Directors, I am excited to announce the appointment of Craig Noonan to the position of Chief Executive Officer (CEO), effective Monday, June 20, 2022.

Craig lives in Summerside with his wife, Kristin, and their 2 teenage children, Makiya and Damon. The Noonan's are a sports-loving family who are actively involved in the community through sports and numerous volunteer initiatives.

A graduate of the University of New Brunswick, with post-graduate training from St. Mary's University in Halifax, and a scholarship recipient from McGill-HEC's Executive MBA program in Montreal, Craig is "passionate about leadership and creating a culture in which team members feel engaged, supported, and appreciated".

Formerly the Chief Operating Officer (COO) at Evangeline-Central Credit Union, Craig currently serves as the Chief Innovation Officer (CIO) of the newly formed Provincial Credit Union. As a member of the executive team, he played a key role in leading and supporting staff and management through the largest merger in the history of Credit Unions in Atlantic Canada.

In addition to his time in the Atlantic Credit Union system, Craig's previous work experiences, education, and service on various boards and committees have provided him a wealth of knowledge and a diverse set of skills over a variety of areas. He brings more than 15 years of senior management experience, including a decade of strategic development and plan execution. Craig has well-rounded expertise in coaching, consulting, business development, sales, marketing, human resources, governance, risk management, and operations – all of which will serve as an asset in his role as CEO.

"I am very excited to join the team at PEI Mutual," said Craig Noonan. "As someone who believes strongly in the organization's values of putting people first, delivering exceptional service and positively impacting our community, this position aligns directly with who I am and everything I stand for. This is a tremendous opportunity to impact our island, and it would be my honor to serve in helping bring the organization forward while building on the history and long-standing traditions that have helped to establish PEI Mutual as one of PEI & Atlantic Canada's most trusted and well-respected companies. "

"Craig is the right leader for PEI Mutual. Our Board is confident that his extensive background as well as his people-focused approach to leadership and building a positive culture will help our team to succeed, strengthen our existing partnerships, provide opportunities to develop new strategic alliances, and empower us to deliver an even greater impact on our Island communities. We believe his experience in innovation and change management will help focus PEI Mutual during the next phase of its evolution, and position him for success in leading the organization and team members through a period of continued growth and transformation."

The Board would also like to extend our sincere thanks to Rudy Smith, who has been serving in the capacity as CFO and Interim CEO since November of 2021. Rudy has been an exceptional support to the Board and staff as well as a tremendous asset to the organization, not only during the past 7-months, but throughout his 21-year career at PEI Mutual. He has exhibited tremendous dedication, diligence, and consistently exceptional leadership, and we would like to recognize his efforts, with gratitude. Upon Craig's arrival, Rudy will resume in his role as Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and will continue to be an integral part of the organization's leadership, working alongside of Craig and other members of the executive team.

Please help us give a warm PEI Mutual welcome to our new CEO, Craig Noonan, on Monday, June 20, 2022!

Thank you.

Shane MacKinnon,
CEO Hiring Committee Chair

Head Office Closing Early Wednesday May 18th


Please be informed that our Head Office will be closing early on Wednesday May 18th at 12pm because of a staff function. The office will reopen for regular hours on Thursday May 19th. Please accept our apologies for any inconvenience caused.

Executive Assistant Position


Are you a highly organized, accurate, and efficient team player with excellent communication skills? Do you take pride in your professionalism, confidentiality, and attention to detail?

After 41 years of dedication to PEI Mutual, our current Executive Assistant is planning a well-deserved retirement, leaving this exciting opportunity available to a new candidate!

PEI Mutual Insurance Company was founded over 137 years ago. With roots in our Island's primary resources, we're proud to be PEI's largest property and casualty insurer.

Responsibilities: As our Executive Assistant you will provide substantial Executive support for the CEO, Officers, and Board of Directors. Job tasks include:

  • Receive, prepare, and direct correspondence, letters, documents, and emails
  • Prepare and distribute agenda and meeting materials, attend meetings, and take minutes for all Board of Director and Head Office staff meetings
  • Organize convention registrations and coordinate travel arrangements
  • Support the CEO in advertising, donations, and promotional initiatives
  • Prepare and distribute agendas, order, and pick up supplies for Agent's meetings
  • Prepare agenda and invitations, coordinate venue and materials associated with the Annual General Meeting
  • Various other general administrative functions, as required
  • An Office Administration diploma or equivalent work experience
  • Excellent attention to detail, time management, and multi-tasking skills
  • Excellent working knowledge of Microsoft Office 365 (Word & Excel)
  • Positive attitude with excellent communication and interpersonal skills
  • Team-oriented, reliable, and well-developed organizational skills
  • Confidential, professional, and ability to handle sensitive information with discretion
We Offer: A rewarding career with a growing and successful Island company that provides attractive compensation and benefits, including:
  • A 37.5 hour work week
  • Paid vacation, sick and medical leave benefits
  • Dental, health and vision care benefits paid by the company
  • An excellent defined-contribution pension plan (RRSP) matched by the company
  • Annual betterment fund benefit and employee wellness challenges
  • Insurance education opportunities
  • The opportunity to work with an inspiring team of co-workers
To Apply: Interested candidates are invited to submit a resume and cover letter in confidence, outlining their strengths in the responsibilities and qualifications to Executive Assistant Position, by Friday, May 6, 2022.

Only candidates selected for an interview will be contacted.


What's New is our way of sharing any important news with our customers. Check back regularly to stay informed about the latest events, meetings and news.