Our Team

Your Trusted Insurance Neighbours!

Based in Summerside, our team of over 60 professionals is passionate about carrying on our 140+ year commitment to exceptional customer service rooted in Island values of kindness, honesty, and community.

We’re more than just insurance providers, we’re your neighbours, your friends, and your partners in protecting what matters most!

Our team of dedicated agents live and work in the communities they serve across PEI. Whether you’re in Tignish, Souris, or anywhere in between, you’ll find an experienced PEI Mutual agent nearby. Their local knowledge ensures you get personalized advice and quick response times when you need them most. Think of our agents as your trusted insurance neighbours!

Directors Executive Leadership Team Service Agents Finance and Administration Human Resources Innovation & IT Marketing & Communications Operations & Executive Support Underwriting Claims

Executive

Craig Noonan

Chief Executive Officer

Rudy Smith

Chief Financial Officer

Leadership Team

Alexa Gallant

Manager, Finance & Administration

Danette Murray

Controller

Jamie Ellis

Manager, Underwriting

Jennifer Pilkington

Manager, Agency

John Shabaan

Manager, IT & Innovation

Josh Toombs

Manager, Claims & In-House Counsel

Lee Gallant

Manager, Marketing & Communications

Mandy Harris

Manager, Human Resources

Service Agents

Eddie Trail

Cascumpec

Paul Power

Summerside

Cameron MacMurdo

North Rustico

Mark MacDonald

Cornwall

Gary Sheehan

Rollo Bay

Jill Abbott

Mermaid

Dave Sigsworth

North Milton

Jeff Trainor

Charlottetown

Kendall Docherty

Hazelbrook

Darren Baglole

Kensington

Colby Callaghan

Miminegash

Jeff McCarthy

Darnley

Josh MacDonald

Murray River

Brad Gallant

North Bedeque

Jamie Newson

Crapaud

Brad Jamieson

Brudenell

Cole MacLaren

Green Meadows

Jeff MacRae

Grand River

Lisa Roche

Launching

Claims

Josh Toombs
Manager, Claims & In-House Counsel Tricia Hashie
Claims Examiner Brittany Quigley
Claims Adjuster Dexter Sellick
Claims Adjuster Tony Gallant
Claims Adjuster Marie Myers
Claims Handler Debbie Jeffery-Desroches
Claims Handler Megan Desroches
Claims Handler Michelle Doucette
Claims Coordinator Lorri-Ann MacLean
Administrative Support Clerk (Claims) Ralph Peters
Equipment Appraiser

Innovation & IT

John Shabaan
Manager, IT & Innovation Andy Gallant
Systems Analyst Andrew Gallant
System Administrator MacKenzie Marchbank
Programmer Deovanto Maitland
IT Support Technician

Finance & Administration

Alexa Gallant
Manager, Finance & Administration Danette Murray
Controller Sandra Arsenault
Receptionist Jolene MacDonald
Accounts Receivable Clerk Charlene Smith
Mail & Administrative Support Clerk Tammy Rogers
Administrative Support Clerk Jenessa Gallant
Administrative Support Clerk Mary Gallant
Administrative Support Clerk Renee Clutterbuck
Accounting Technician Nicole Richard
Accounting Technician Christie-Anne Campbell
Accounting Technician Alexis Kelly
Summer Student – Administrative Support Joel Compton
Summer Student – Administrative Support

Human Resources

Mandy Harris
Manager, Human Resources Gavin Gong
Human Resources Coordinator

Marketing & Communications

Lee Gallant
Manager, Marketing & Communications Lauren Johnston
Summer Student Intern

Operations & Executive Support

Alyssa MacLean
Operations Coordinator

Underwriting

Jamie Ellis
Manager, Underwriting Faustina Murray
Supervisor, Underwriting Services Sheila Cochrane
Underwriter Matthew Kelly
Underwriter Carol Waddell
Member Service Advisor Jennifer Goeseels
Member Service Advisor Ashley Thompson
Member Service Advisor Lorena Milligan
Data Entry Clerk Tanya Laforest
Data Entry Clerk Gary Bryson
Safety Surveyor Elliot Olscamp
Safety Surveyor