Your Trusted Insurance Neighbours!
Based in Summerside, our team of over 60 professionals is passionate about carrying on our 140+ year commitment to exceptional customer service rooted in Island values of kindness, honesty, and community.
We're more than just insurance providers, we're your neighbours, your friends, and your partners in protecting what matters most!
Our team of dedicated agents live and work in the communities they serve across PEI. Whether you're in Tignish, Souris, or anywhere in between, you'll find an experienced PEI Mutual agent nearby. Their local knowledge ensures you get personalized advice and quick response times when you need them most. Think of our agents as your trusted insurance neighbours!
Executive
Craig Noonan
Rudy Smith
Leadership Team
Alexa Gallant
Danette Murray
Jamie Ellis
Jennifer Pilkington
John Shabaan
Josh Toombs
Lee Gallant
Mandy Harris
Service Agents
Eddie Trail
Paul Power
Cameron MacMurdo
Mark MacDonald
Gary Sheehan
Jill Abbott
Dave Sigsworth
Jeff Trainor
Kendall Docherty
Darren Baglole
Colby Callaghan
Jeff McCarthy
Josh MacDonald
Brad Gallant
Jamie Newson
Brad Jamieson
Cole MacLaren
Lisa Roche
Claims
Josh Toombs
Manager, Claims & In-House Counsel
Tricia Hashie
Claims Examiner
Brittany Quigley
Claims Adjuster
Dexter Sellick
Claims Adjuster
Tony Gallant
Claims Adjuster
Marie Myers
Claims Handler
Debbie Jeffery-Desroches
Claims Handler
Megan Desroches
Claims Handler
Michelle Doucette
Claims Coordinator
Lorri-Ann MacLean
Administrative Support Clerk (Claims)
Ralph Peters
Equipment Appraiser
Innovation & IT
John Shabaan
Manager, IT & Innovation
Andy Gallant
Systems Analyst
Andrew Gallant
System Administrator
MacKenzie Marchbank
Programmer
Finance & Administration
Alexa Gallant
Manager, Finance & Administration
Danette Murray
Controller
Sandra Arsenault
Receptionist
Jolene MacDonald
Accounts Receivable Clerk
Charlene Smith
Mail & Administrative Support Clerk
Tammy Rogers
Administrative Support Clerk
Jenessa Gallant
Administrative Support Clerk
Mary Gallant
Administrative Support Clerk
Renee Clutterbuck
Accounting Technician
Nicole Richard
Accounting Technician
Christie-Anne Campbell
Accounting Technician
Human Resources
Mandy Harris
Manager, Human Resources
Marketing & Communications
Lee Gallant
Manager, Marketing & Communications
Operations & Executive Support
Alyssa MacLean
Operations Coordinator
Underwriting
Jamie Ellis
Manager, Underwriting
Faustina Murray
Supervisor, Underwriting Services
Sheila Cochrane
Underwriter
Matthew Kelly
Underwriter
Carol Waddell
Member Service Advisor
Jennifer Goeseels
Member Service Advisor
Ashley Thompson
Member Service Advisor
Lorena Milligan
Data Entry Clerk
Tanya Laforest
Data Entry Clerk
Gary Bryson
Safety Surveyor
Elliot Olscamp
Safety Surveyor
Stephen MacKinnon
Summer Student